Nightwatch logo
'Nightwatch' text with white and gray letters
Historical Intelligence

Situation Report

Archived operational intelligence briefing

Report Time
2024-12-12 09:57:08Z
1 year ago
Previous (2024-12-12 09:10:04Z)

Okay, here's the analysis of the provided information, combined and presented in a structured format:

Updated Operational Situation Overview - December 12, 2024 (09:56:20 UTC)

Executive Summary:

The situation in Ukraine remains highly dynamic, with Russian forces continuing their advances in the east, particularly around Kurakhovo and Pokrovsk, alongside increased activity in the Kursk and Sumy regions. Drone warfare is intensifying on both sides. Ukraine is facing internal challenges including declining morale, logistical issues, and corruption allegations. Both sides are engaging in intense information warfare. Russia is showing signs of internal issues, including corruption and low morale, but is also increasing its border operations, counter-terrorism activities and recruiting. The international landscape is shifting, with potential peacekeeping missions being discussed and economic uncertainties impacting both sides. The situation in Syria has also become volatile following the collapse of the Assad regime.

Key Developments:

  • Eastern Front Intensification:

    • Kurakhovo: Russian forces are advancing from the south, south west, and north west. Fighting within Kurakhovo is reported, particularly in the Yuzhnyy district. Supply lines are severely impacted, and the western exit is threatened. There is also Russian movement in Shevchenko, a city to the west of Kurakhovo.
    • Pokrovsk: Russian forces are aggressively pushing south, and are entering fortified positions without a fight.
    • Kupyansk: Fighting continues in the Kupyansk area, with Ukrainian forces reportedly repelling Russian advances.
    • Toretsk/Kramatorsk Direction: Intense fighting around Toretsk, Chasiv Yar, and Stupochky. Toretsk is under Russian air attack.
    • Kursk and Sumy Oblasts: Russian forces continue to advance, with successful advances in the Sudzha district, particularly near Novoivanovka, and further advances in Sumy Oblast, forcing Ukrainian retreats. Ukrainian forces have reportedly repelled 22 Russian assaults in the Kursk region, conflicting with Russian claims of a successful offensive. Russian forces have reportedly liberated Daryino.
    • Lyman Axis: Active fighting is occurring in the areas around Tverdokhlibove, Druzhelubivka, Novoyehorivka, Hrekivka, Makiyivka, Terny, Torske, Hryhorivka, Kopanka and the Serebryanskyi forest.
  • Drone Warfare: Drones are increasingly critical for both sides, used for attacks, reconnaissance, and electronic warfare. Ukraine has used ATACMS missiles in Taganrog. Russia is employing Lancet drones to target Ukrainian aircraft on the ground. A Ukrainian "Plastun-3000" electronic warfare station was destroyed by a Russian FPV operator. Ukrainian drone teams are targeting Russian fortifications and armor in the Kupyansk area.

  • Logistics & Morale:

    • Ukraine is experiencing a decline in conscription numbers, a sign they are not keeping up with losses. There are reports of Ukrainian soldiers being ordered to commit suicide rather than be captured. Logistical challenges are a major issue, as is low morale amongst Ukrainian troops. Ukrainian commanders are reportedly "worse than the enemy."
    • The Russian military is also suffering from corruption and low morale. There are reports of Russian soldiers having to build bunkers using their own funds.
  • Syria: Russia is withdrawing forces from Syria but maintaining naval assets. Instability and infighting persist.

  • Internal Security: Ukrainian internal security forces have made arrests related to a Shariy Party member plotting to overthrow the government, and have arrested a network of propagandists taking orders from outside Ukraine. Russia is increasing counter-terrorism activities in border regions and launched a recruitment campaign in Crimea for FSB recruits.

  • Economic/Social Issues: Russian state media is facing issues related to transportation, housing, medical, and social payments. In Russia there is an increased trend of women returning dresses after work events.

  • Propaganda: Both sides actively deploy propaganda to undermine the morale of their opponent's population.

  • Specific Unit Actions:

    • Ukrainian forces in Kupiansk have targeted Russian armor and fortifications.
    • Ukrainian snipers are also working in that area, targeting enemy personnel.
    • A unit using "Molniya" (Lightning) UAVs is operating on the Kursk front, targeting enemy armor.
    • The Russian 5th Separate Motorized Rifle Brigade was given an honorary title despite numerous reports of its human rights abuses, including torture. The same organization is implicated in the death of an American journalist.
    • A video from a Russian soldier highlights the dangerous work of vehicle recovery in a conflict zone.
  • Political and Geopolitical:

    • A meeting has taken place between Dmitry Medvedev and Xi Jinping in China.
    • A Polish official suggests a ceasefire in Ukraine is imminent and reconstruction might begin in 2025.
    • The possibility of a NATO peacekeeping force deployment to Ukraine after the "hot" phase of the war is actively being discussed. Poland and France are considering 40,000 peacekeepers.
    • The U.S. Congress removed lend-lease from the 2025 budget.
    • The Ukrainian government is discussing the return of refugees from Germany.
    • Germany is sending aid to Ukraine, primarily focused on energy infrastructure.
  • Ukraine is discussing restrictions on Telegram due to disinformation concerns.

  • Internal Issues:

    • There have been public outcries regarding the price of coffins being too high in Ukraine, and also extortion of money from injured soldiers. Protests against conscription are surging in urban centers. There are widespread reports of theft and looting in Ukrainian rear areas.
    • In Russia there are issues related to mass conscription, low morale, economic issues, and corruption.

Updated Assessment of Key Areas:

  • Eastern Ukraine: Russian forces continue to make significant advances, especially near Kurakhovo, and are putting pressure on Pokrovsk and Toretsk. Ukrainian forces are struggling to hold defensive positions and are losing ground. Intense fighting continues across Donbas and in Lyman. Supply lines to Kurakhovo have been severed. Ukrainian forces lack resources and command structure and have severe communication problems.
  • Russian Operations in Kursk and Sumy Oblasts: Russian forces are continuing to advance in these regions, focusing on territorial control. Ukrainian forces are using drone attacks in the Kursk region, but this has not slowed the advances. Russia is increasing its border operations.
  • Drone Warfare: Drones are increasingly used by both sides for reconnaissance, surveillance, and targeted attacks, including FPV drones and kamikaze drones. There is a critical need for effective counter-drone measures. Russia is using drones to target Ukrainian air assets on the ground.
  • Information Warfare: Both sides actively engage in information warfare, attempting to undermine opponent morale and influence public opinion through propaganda. Social media is a critical part of these operations. Ukraine is considering more restrictions on Telegram as a source of disinformation.
  • Internal Security: Both Ukraine and Russia are actively working to prevent and deter internal threats. Russia is increasing counter-terrorism operations in border regions. Ukraine is arresting Shariy Party members and propagandists to undermine internal destabilization.
  • Economic Instability: The Russian economy is showing continued signs of struggle with evidence of corruption, economic uncertainty, and decreased stability. Ukrainian forces are suffering from significant logistical issues, a direct symptom of resource limitation.
  • Humanitarian Crisis: Civilian casualties continue to rise, particularly in areas heavily targeted by missiles and artillery. Civilian access to basic medical services is a primary concern, especially for displaced peoples. There is a clear need for humanitarian support.

Updated Strategic Recommendations for Commanders:

  1. Strengthen Defenses: Fortify key locations of Pokrovsk and Kurakhove due to heightened Russian military activity. Enhance defenses against advancing Russian forces in the Sumy and Dnipropetrovsk regions. Improve fortifications and counter-battery measures to better defend the region. Increase focus on securing transport arteries leading to Kurakhove. Deploy forces to secure and protect fortified positions to prevent them from being captured without a fight.
  2. Address Troop Morale: Counter Russian psychological operations by developing and implementing strategies to boost morale. Investigate claims of low morale, as well as any claims of internal corruption. Address logistical challenges to ensure troops are well supported. Work to improve communication between leadership and combat troops. Address widespread reports of theft and looting in Ukrainian rear areas. Investigate the validity of reports regarding orders to commit suicide instead of being captured.
  3. Enhance Air and Counter-Drone Measures: Prioritize air defense and deploy effective counter-drone measures and new counter-drone technology. Research new methods of defense to deal with the ever increasing threat from drones. Focus on drone countermeasures. Improve Ukrainian intelligence capabilities to counteract increasingly effective Russian use of drones. Increase mine-clearance operations, particularly around Selidovo.
  4. Secure Supply Lines: Evaluate and secure logistical routes and find alternate paths to prevent disruptions. Address the impact of Ukrainian banks reducing card-to-card transfer limits. Address the significant gaps in Ukrainian defensive lines, prioritizing the areas between Velyka Novosilka and Kurakhovo, and Kurakhovo and Pokrovsk.
  5. Target Financial Networks: Actively work to identify and target Russian financial networks used to support military operations. Investigate and address corruption leading to supply chain issues. Investigate the "RUSORIZ" bank account.
  6. Enhance Drone Capabilities: Develop and deploy advanced drone technology for both surveillance and attacks, focusing on drone countermeasures. Increase focus on securing transport arteries leading to Kurakhove. Account for the emergence of new Ukrainian drone designs.
  7. Counter Russian Propaganda: Develop and implement an effective counter-information strategy to combat Russian narratives. Address information warfare tactics, and provide clear and consistent counter-narratives. Address the significant gaps in Ukrainian defensive lines, prioritizing the areas between Velyka Novosilka and Kurakhovo, and Kurakhovo and Pokrovsk. Address growing use of disinformation campaigns by both sides. Counter Russian disinformation regarding incursions into Sumy Oblast. Analyze and track disinformation and propaganda being pushed by all parties involved in the conflict, and adjust messaging accordingly. Address the potential for increased cyber warfare capabilities and disinformation.
  8. Focus on Internal Stability: Continue counterintelligence and law enforcement operations to disrupt internal threats, including pro-Russian political networks. Focus on uncovering and mitigating internal sabotage efforts. Investigate any reports of faulty munitions. Address growing use of disinformation campaigns by both sides.
  9. Civilian Protection: Prioritize civilian protection and support services for internally displaced people. Maintain medical support and communication. Address unexploded ordnance concerns. Address the humanitarian crisis in Ukraine, including the rising civilian casualties. Support the development and maintenance of resilience centers in high-risk areas. Provide support to those affected by the mass evacuation order in Yenakiieve and Zlatopole. Address the impact of the ammunition depot detonation in Yenakiieve.
  10. Address Sanctions Circumvention: Work with international partners to limit Russia’s ability to circumvent international sanctions.
  11. Address the Syrian Instability: Closely monitor the situation in Syria and analyze potential impacts on regional stability. Monitor Iranian attempts to maintain influence in the region following the fall of Assad's regime. Monitor Israel's potential occupation of Damascus. Monitor the Syrian opposition's withdrawal from captured cities.
  12. Investigate Claims of Election Interference: Investigate claims of Russian interference in the Romanian elections.
  13. Monitor Russian Mobilization Efforts: Monitor and analyze Russian mobilization and recruitment campaigns.
  14. Prepare for CBRN Threats: Prepare for potential chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear threats by having appropriate equipment and training.
  15. Address Potential for EU Peacekeepers: Further analyze the potential deployment of European Peacekeepers and the implications this could have for the conflict, as well as post conflict operations. Closely monitor the potential deployment of international peacekeeping forces to Ukraine, and consider the impacts these would have on both current operations and future scenarios.
  16. Address Disinformation: Analyze and track disinformation and propaganda being pushed by all parties involved in the conflict, and adjust messaging accordingly. Assess the nature and implications of the pro-Russian messaging channels operating on Telegram. Analyze and track disinformation and propaganda being pushed by all parties involved in the conflict, and adjust messaging accordingly. Address concerns regarding the use of Telegram as a vector for disinformation and potential espionage. Identify and disrupt Ukrainian operations using call centers and similar for disinformation and recruitment. Counter Russian disinformation regarding incursions into Sumy Oblast.
  17. Improve Logistical Operations: Improve logistical operations, particularly in areas experiencing supply chain failures. Investigate and address corruption leading to supply chain issues. Improve logistical support for Ukrainian drone units. Address the logistical challenges highlighted by the Ukrainian military officer's testimony regarding the mobilization efforts. Address the critical logistical failures contributing to low morale and abandonment of troops, especially in Kurakhovo. Address widespread reports of theft and looting in Ukrainian rear areas. Address the potential impact of Ukrainian banks reducing card-to-card transfer limits.
  18. Monitor Military Operations: Continue active intelligence and surveillance of all military activity to assess strengths and weaknesses. Continue to monitor the ongoing conflict and look for weaknesses or potential vulnerabilities for exploitation. Monitor for acts of sabotage within Russia and Ukraine, paying particular attention to potential Ukrainian operations using online recruiting and targeting critical infrastructure. Improve intelligence capabilities to counteract increasingly effective Russian use of drones. Increase focus on identifying and neutralizing potential sabotage efforts inside Russia. Monitor the potential for internal instability within Russia given the video appeal from residents of the settlement of Perevalovo in the Tyumen Oblast. Address reports of corruption within Ukrainian military and civilian organizations. Assess the implications of the large-scale Israeli strike on Latakia. Monitor Iranian attempts to maintain influence in the region following the fall of Assad's regime. Monitor Israel's potential occupation of Damascus. Monitor the Syrian opposition's withdrawal from captured cities. Closely monitor the situation in Manbij and Turkish involvement. Monitor Israeli operations closely. Monitor the potential impact of HTS being removed from the terrorist list. Monitor the Russian withdrawal from Syria.
  19. Assess Impact of Economic and Political Instability: Continue to monitor and assess the impact of economic and political instability both in Russia and in Ukraine.
  20. Address Reports of Atrocities: Investigate and address the reports of atrocities, particularly those coming from Kursk Oblast (POW camp strike and other incidents) and from Syria (public execution, execution of wounded soldiers). Investigate and address reports of extrajudicial killings, particularly those involving surrendering combatants and the use of drones. Clarify rules of engagement to prevent similar incidents.
  21. Assess the impact of the reported deaths of prominent Syrian figures, including a chemist and a theologian.
  22. Address the large-scale surrender of Syrian soldiers.
  23. Address the potential for increased ballistic missile attacks from Belarus.
  24. Address the increased frequency of air raid sirens in Western and Northern Ukraine.
  25. Assess the implications of the resumption of Russian passenger rail service with China and North Korea.
  26. Address the potential impact of the reported inappropriate behavior of a Scottish council leader toward Ukrainian refugees.
  27. Assess the implications of the proposed Ukrainian arms export policy.
  28. Monitor Weather Conditions: Account for the impact of severe weather conditions on military operations and civilian populations. Address the water shortages in the LNR. Address the impact of severe weather on troop morale and operational readiness. Note that adverse weather conditions may be impacting Russian drone operations.
  29. Address the Potential for Increased Use of Long-Range Ballistic Missiles: Assess and respond to the potential for increased Russian use of long-range ballistic missiles. Note that Russia is reportedly capable of producing 25 Oreshnik missiles per month.
  30. Address the Confirmed Presence of Nuclear Weapons in Belarus: Reassess the threat level posed by the confirmed presence of nuclear weapons in Belarus. Address the confirmed presence of nuclear weapons in Belarus and Lukashenko's statements regarding their use.
  31. Address Internal Corruption: Address reports of widespread corruption and extortion within both the military and civilian populations in Ukraine. Address the apparent lack of accountability within the Ukrainian military command structure. Investigate reports of faulty munitions being supplied to front-line units.

Conclusion:

The operational situation remains highly unstable and volatile. Russian forces are pressing their advances in eastern Ukraine, focusing on strategic objectives in key areas like Pokrovsk, Kurakhovo, and Toretsk. The increase of activity in Kursk and Sumy presents a new front that needs to be addressed. Drones are playing a critical role in all these operations. Ukrainian forces are facing serious challenges with significant logistical deficiencies, supply chain failures, decreasing morale, internal communication failures, and the increasing rate of casualties. Russia's military is also showing signs of strain and internal problems related to logistics, morale, and corruption. Both sides are actively engaged in information campaigns, which are designed to undermine their opponents while building support among their own populations. The international landscape is shifting, including potential peacekeeping operations being considered, a possible end to the "hot" phase of the war, an increased emphasis on cybersecurity and digital security, and shifts in economic relationships between countries. The Syrian situation continues to be volatile and may pose a risk to future stability. A clear strategy to counter-information, to combat internal dissent and corruption, and to limit the effects of sanctions circumvention is required for the war effort to continue successfully. The increasing sophistication and widespread use of drones by both sides requires a reassessment of current countermeasures. The reported Russian advances near Kurakhovo and the HIMARS strike on Yenakiieve represent significant escalations. The potential for increased use of long-range ballistic missiles by Russia needs to be factored into all strategic calculations. The ongoing mobilization challenges in Ukraine, particularly concerning the potential lowering of the conscription age, present a critical situation requiring further analysis. The confirmation of nuclear weapons in Belarus necessitates a reassessment of the threat level. The large-scale Israeli strikes in Syria represent a significant escalation and may provoke further regional instability. The ammunition depot detonation in Yenakiieve and subsequent evacuation orders necessitate a rapid humanitarian response. The increased reports of civilian casualties in Zlatopole require an immediate reassessment of targeting strategies and defensive measures. The reports of corruption and extortion within both the military and civilian populations in Ukraine require urgent attention and a decisive strategy to address these issues. The potential for further escalation in the conflict given the ongoing Russian offensive and the deployment of long-range ballistic missiles is a primary concern. The ongoing internal security challenges within Russia, including the arrests of suspected saboteurs, require enhanced counter-intelligence efforts. The video showing the apparent extrajudicial killing of a surrendering soldier by a drone highlights the need for immediate clarification of the rules of engagement to prevent similar events. The significant shortage of drones for Ukrainian forces is a critical vulnerability. The apparent lack of effective command and control in the Ukrainian military is also a major concern. The concentration of 150,000 Russian troops across three axes in eastern Ukraine represents a significant escalation. The large number of reported desertions and missing soldiers within the Ukrainian military is deeply concerning. The reported use of cluster munitions in Yenakiieve represents a serious violation of international law. The death of a prominent Syrian chemist and theologian suggests a potential targeting of intellectual and academic leadership. The mass surrender of Syrian soldiers indicates a significant collapse of morale and combat effectiveness. The potential for increased ballistic missile attacks from Belarus requires increased vigilance and preparedness. The increased frequency of air raid sirens in Western and Northern Ukraine necessitates immediate attention to civilian safety. The resumption of Russian passenger rail service with China and North Korea has significant geopolitical implications. The reported inappropriate behavior of a Scottish council leader towards Ukrainian refugees may have indirect consequences on the perception and efficacy of humanitarian aid. The proposed policy shift regarding the export of Ukrainian weapons requires careful consideration of both its economic and strategic benefits and risks.

The situation continues to evolve rapidly. Continuous monitoring and proactive adaptation are vital. New information suggests a change in momentum from recent gains made by Russian forces as Ukraine is making an effort to address the Russian advance. However, serious issues are still impacting the Ukrainian effort, and a decisive strategy is needed to maintain the fight against Russian aggression.

This analysis reflects all available information up to the current time (Thu Dec 12 09:56:20 2024).

Previous (2024-12-12 09:10:04Z)

We only use optional analytics cookies if you allow them. Necessary cookies stay on for sign-in and site security.

Learn more in our Privacy Policy.